Letter: Universal insurance should be paid for through taxes


To the editor:

Maybe now is a good time to ask ourselves “What is the point of healthcare insurance?” Hopefully, we all answer “To share the risk”.

We all know we are going to have an illness or injury and need medical care sooner or later. We know that for some of us that care will be ruinously expensive. But we can’t know exactly when we will need care or how much it will cost. So we band together into a pool and agree to share the risk. Insurance is the system by which we all chip in together so that when we need medical care we will be able to get it and not be destroyed by the cost. It’s a smart thing to do. In fact, insurance companies understand the value of sharing risk. They’re not stupid. That’s why they set up risk pools for themselves. Google it.

People without insurance still need healthcare and they still get it. They may not get all the care they need when it would be best and least expensive to get it, but when they’re hit by a bus or catastrophically ill they get “free care” from the hospital. The costs of this care don’t disappear, but are bundled into what is covered by our insurance premiums. And those costs are often larger than they needed to be if the person had access to preventative and routine care.

Inarguably, hundreds of thousands of families are bankrupted every year by medical bills. And their misfortune costs the rest of us plenty. As noted above, we pay for the medical costs they can’t pay for. But that’s not the end of it. Parents lose their homes and jobs and need public assistance. Children are traumatized and their education and development suffer. You get the idea. These are significant societal costs that affect us all.

Everyone should be covered by insurance. Although we love the phrase “freedom of choice,” it’s not rational to leave it up to the individual to choose whether to be insured. Think about why we insist that everyone carry liability insurance as a requirement to drive. If someone hits me, I shouldn’t have to pay to repair my car. We may be willing for people to gamble with their own money, but we generally don’t want other people to gamble with ours. But that’s what happens when people choose not to carry medical insurance.

The insurance covering Americans should be fair. Right now, we’re all playing a warped lottery where the insurance you can get—what it covers and what it costs you—depends on whether you’ve been lucky enough to keep full-time work and who your employer happens to be. How is it fair for me to have lavish healthcare insurance that covers every procedure and prescription without copays or deductibles while my neighbor has only crummy insurance that is the best her employer can afford to offer? Meanwhile, another neighbor is on Medicaid and has trouble finding providers that accept it and yet another neighbor is simply uninsured. 

Logically, it makes most sense to insure all Americans with coverage that we all chip in to pay for: universal insurance paid for through taxes.

If we think it through, there is no real reason to even have a private healthcare insurance industry in the first place. It is an artifact left over from the past. Insurance companies add tremendously to the costs of healthcare insurance. How much could we save if we didn’t have to pay for their advertising and marketing, the bloated salaries and benefits paid to their executives, the administrative costs of the legions of workers hired to find excuses to deny claims, and the record profits they bank every year?

Our healthcare insurance system could be better. It should be better. We ought to work together to make it better. The Republican proposal now in Congress goes in exactly the wrong direction.


Tim Mize



6 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
joe sousa

Social Security Medicare Medicaid and now another tax on working people. I'll take my chances in a free market system. Open the borders and let me shop in other states for a plan that fits me. Tort reform, set limits on claims.

Big Government is not cost efficient as we all well know. "The Affordable Health Care act" Democrats answer to health care, yea right any thing but.

Sunday, March 19 | Report this

Stated more simply and much shorter - and without loaded words like "inarguably" -- the writer wants healthcare bills paid by someone else.

Does the writer intends "coverage we all chip in to pay for" to mean everyone pays the same dollar amount or even the same tax rate?

US health costs are much higher than any other country. Honest advocates of universal healthcare will state that it involves either much higher taxes or government rationing, or both.

Sunday, March 19 | Report this

Excellent letter, Mr. Mize. Thank you for you opinion.

Monday, March 20 | Report this

Yes, thank you Mr. Mize. We need a single payer system, which would not only help people, but small businesses as well. We all pay for health care for those that don't have or cannot afford health insurance - we just pay a much higher price. It is en EVERYONE's best interest to pay for coverage for all, increase preventative care, and eliminate the outrageous number of bankruptcies due to medical bills. When did compassion completely die in America???

Tuesday, March 21 | Report this
Tim Mize

Anyone who thinks there can be a free market for healthcare insurance understands neither free markets not healthcare insurance.

Tort reform is probably a good idea as it drives healthcare costs up. There must remain, however, a reasonable ability to sue for malpractice.

Monday, March 27 | Report this
joe sousa

The ability to shop for insurance in a competitive market, our not shop at all. Stay out of my pocket type freedom. Liberals always think their entitled to others money. They make up fake statistics ,then use them to push the big government solutions. well guess what they don't work $19'854'576'345'894

U.S. National Debt Clock : Real Time


US National Debt Clock : Real Time U.S. National Debt Clock.

Monday, March 27 | Report this

2016 by East Bay Newspapers

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Prudence Island · Riverside · Rumford · Seekonk · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.