Talking Politics

The train is starting to roll toward a decisive CD1 Primary

By Ian Donnis
Posted 3/27/23

STORY OF THE WEEK: If the election to succeed David Cicilline in the 1 st Congressional District was held last Friday, the favorites were Lt. Gov. Sabina Matos and state Sen. Sandra Cano …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Register to post events

If you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here.

Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content.

Day pass subscribers

Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.

Talking Politics

The train is starting to roll toward a decisive CD1 Primary


STORY OF THE WEEK: If the election to succeed David Cicilline in the 1st Congressional District was held last Friday, the favorites were Lt. Gov. Sabina Matos and state Sen. Sandra Cano (D-Pawtucket). Both have a record of winning elections; Cano got the most votes as a Biden delegate in CD1 in 2020, while Matos was the top Biden delegate choice in CD2.

Matos won statewide in November, while Cano has traditionally been a top choice for voters in her community, as a city councilor and state lawmaker. The presence of (at least) two Latinas in the CD1 race reflects the maturation of Latino politics in Rhode Island. Neither candidate was swimming in campaign cash as of the last state filing: Cano had about $28,000 and Matos less than $500. But that was then and this is now. Cano and Matos can expect to have labor support, with education unions favoring Cano, and trade unions preferring Matos – an especially significant factor in what is shaping up as a large field of candidates.

Since this column posted online last Friday, state Rep. Stephen Casey of Woonsocket and Ward 1 Providence City Councilor John Goncalves have joined the CD1 race, making for at least seven

Democrats (including Rep. Nathan Biah of Providence, former Raimondo staffer Nick Autiello, and former Republican Allen Waters), with House Speaker Joe Shekarchi and former gov candidate Helena Foulkes ruling out a run.

A number of potential candidates remain on the sidelines, including Pawtucket Mayor Don Grebien, White House staffer Gabe Amo, a Pawtucket native (unlike current officeholders, he would have to leave his job to pursue a run), and renewable energy investor Don Carlson of Jamestown. The array of other possible candidates extends from House Finance Chairman Marvin Abney of Newport to Central Falls Mayor Maria Rivera and other aspirants. The primary election in either August or September is likely to be decisive, given the Democratic lean of CD1. For those on the sidelines time is passing fast, since candidates are moving quickly to build up behind-the-scenes support. As former NEARI executive director Robert A. Walsh Jr. puts it, “The train is leaving the station.” 

SLOWDOWN: The May revenue estimating conference will reveal whether a state budget surplus once estimated in the neighborhood of $600 million has taken a big hit. As it stands, the effect of higher interest rates is already evident in Rhode Island, with a delay in issuing bonds for the Pawtucket soccer stadium project and questions about how the Superman revitalization may be affected. As this column noted last week, it remains unclear if the Fed’s management of the economy, with super-low interest rates for a very long stretch, may usher in an extended downturn.

FOULKES’ FUTURE: Former CVS exec Helena Buonanno Foulkes this week ruled out a run in CD1, saying in part that she thinks she can make a bigger impact by working on local issues in Rhode Island. Foulkes finished strong in her campaign for governor last year, losing to Dan McKee by three points. She sketched out her local efforts during an interview on Political Roundtable. Asked if she expects to run for governor in 2026 – a huge distance away in political time – Foulkes said, “I really don't know. I mean, I'm not running for anything right now. I'm trying to help locally and give back. And I just don't know what the world will look like in three years’ time – what will I, what my personal life will be like, or what the state of the state will be.”

GENERAL ASSEMBLY: State lawmakers in Rhode Island typically treat one another, during sharp debates and routine matters alike, with courtesy and respect. But the usual course of dialogue blew up when Rep. Robert Quattrocchi (R-Scituate), during a recent committee hearing, asked Rep. Rebecca Kislak (D-Providence) – a lesbian woman – if she is a pedophile. This came during discussion of a Kislak proposal to view the impact of proposed legislation through an equity lens. Quattrocchi asked if the impact would be assessed on Satanists and pedophiles.

As a result of the remarks, House Speaker Joe Shekarchi this week removed Quattrocchi (R-Scituate) from the Committee on State Government and Elections. Republicans cried foul, saying Democrats made too much of the matter and they see inconsistency in how discipline gets meted out. In his own remarks on the House floor, Quattrocchi described receiving threatening and offensive messages. Democrats, meanwhile, said some response was needed to restore decorum.

PAYDAY: Advocates are once again trying to change Rhode Island’s dubious distinction as a place that allows payday lenders to charge the equivalent of triple-digit interest on loans. Legislative leaders have for years been unwilling of tackling this issue, as I reported in 2021. Attorney General Peter Neronha this week called the status quo “indefensible,” and his Democratic colleagues have called out the payday lending industry. It remains to be seen whether advocates will muster the kind of effort needed to make a change.

REPUBLICAN THUNDER: Joe Powers, who lost a race for state Senate in Cranston last year, won election last weekend as the new RI GOP chair. Here is a brief Q&A.

What is your vision for the RI GOP?

Powers: “A more unified, structured and well-funded party. Our goal is to fundraise to allow for us to build an infrastructure to support the right candidates for the General Assembly and support all 39 city and town committees across the state.”

What should Republicans do differently to win more General Assembly seats?

Powers: “Communication is key to the party’s success, and not just within the party but with the constituents of Rhode Island. We need to be the party that lets the constituents know who we are and what we actually stand [for] and not allow others to do so. We also need to devise a plan to leverage the election tools available to us, in order to win the seats, in order to effect change for Rhode Island.

Who is your preferred choice for president next year?

Powers: “Right now, my focus is on the RI GOP Chair and then the special election for CD1. With that being said, it’s going to be an interesting race for sure and I am looking forward to seeing who all of the candidates will be for us to choose from. Regardless of who it is, I'm certain the Republican Party will have a candidate that will get the country heading in a better direction than it has seen with the current administration.”

Political hero?

Powers: “Ronald Reagan – The Great Communicator.”

Favorite restaurant?

Powers: “Marchetti's Restaurant in Knightsville. Amazing food, atmosphere and family-owned business for over 40 years.”


Takes of the Week – various views from a mix of Rhode Islanders. 

CORTNEY NICOLATO, president/CEO of the United Way of Rhode Island: “Rhode Island’s nonprofits are the anchors of our cities and towns. This isn’t hyperbole; it is fact and one of my core beliefs. Nearly one in five Rhode Islanders go to work each day at a nonprofit (not including the tens of thousands of volunteers who gift of their time and talents), and cumulatively, these organizations are an economic engine generating more than $13 billion in annual revenue.

“All 365 days a year, RI’s nonprofits provide essential social services, educate our children, and help to build thriving, healthy, and prosperous communities. All of us have been affected by the impact of nonprofits in our community. One week from now will be our fourth 401Gives, a weekend to celebrate the sector and to donate to the organizations that have given so much to us. Rhode Islanders are incredible at helping Rhode Islanders and 401Gives has shown that. Here’s hoping this year is our biggest yet – let’s show big love to our nonprofits, they deserve it.”

Historian and RI GOP National Committeeman STEVE FRIAS: “Passing more laws to override local control over land use will likely not reduce the cost of housing in Rhode Island. In fact, it may prove to be counter-productive. As explained by land use scholar William Fischel, state housing policies which override local control can ‘encourage a backlash against all development, ultimately making the whole region’s housing less affordable.’ State mandates, which impose a one-size fits all approach, are generally unworkable, and will likely meet with local resistance.

“Every potential housing development can be unique, with differing impacts on a local neighborhood, schools, municipal infrastructure, parking or traffic. If state officials really want to [get] more housing built, they should recognize the reality that building more housing usually has a negative fiscal impact on municipalities. Rather than passing laws which try to take away local control, the state should financially incentivize municipalities to approve the building of more housing. It would certainly be a better use of taxpayer money than spending it on a silly minor league soccer stadium.”

MICHAEL ROLES, policy director for Climate Jobs Rhode Island: “While this week’s UN climate panel report renewed greater urgency for climate action, here in Rhode Island, we continue to feel the impacts of decades of disinvestment in our kids. Getting every Rhode Island public school to net zero energy by 2035 will help safeguard our future, while enabling healthy learning environments for those who will inherit that future.

“With mold, poor ventilation, and leaky roofs, the average age of Rhode Island's school buildings is 50 years, compounding already-high asthma rates, affecting learning outcomes, and costing school districts a total estimated $35.2 million. We have a once-in-a generation opportunity to turn things around today by leveraging money approved by voters last year, along with federal programs that can cover 30% to 40% of the cost of projects. Research by Climate Jobs Rhode Island shows that the return on investment in energy savings for school districts could be seven years, on average.”

Consultant and former state Rep. LIANA CASSAR of Barrington: “The ramp-up to 401Gives on April 1 is underway. Our state’s amazing annual day of giving coincides this year with the date when 350,000 Rhode Islanders will be thrust into limbo. That’s because the end of the public health emergency means the beginning of having to prove they’re poor, once again, just so they can keep their Medicaid coverage.

“While the timing is coincidental, it is striking how both events provide a lens into the issue of poverty in RI – almost 1 in 3 people will be at risk of losing or experiencing a gap in health care coverage, and this year's 401Gives may raise more funds for the nonprofit sector than in years past. We should all deeply appreciate and invest as we can in the work that the United Way has done to create opportunities for RI’s nonprofit sector to thrive. But why the state needs the plethora of nonprofits and why those groups need to be doing major fundraising to help meet many Rhode Islanders’ basic needs highlights a systemic problem.

“As our state’s economy grows, demand for the services of the R.I. Food Bank should be getting smaller, yet the opposite is happening. The state’s growing wealth disparity is an urgent problem for every sector in the state to get involved in solving. We cannot leave it to philanthropy to address the needs of increasing numbers of folks finding themselves in economic distress and we cannot depend on charity to make for a more financially equitable society.

Former RI Democratic Party chairman and consultant Guy Dufault: “ ‘Trump willing to take a ‘perp walk’! Trump will get stronger if he’s indicted!’ These and other Trump misnomers about his potential indictment do a disservice to legitimate political discourse. An indictment, while possibly helping his small dollar MAGA donations, will be devastating to his overall electability.

“For Trump to capture the swing states necessary for a 2024 win, he would need to move about one million independent leaning voters to his column, in five states. Through recent polling data, these independent voters overwhelmingly see an indictment as a reason to move away from Trump. There just won’t be enough electorate available to him to win. While Mr. Trump may embrace an indictment, the reality is we will finally see the political end of Donald Trump.”

MEDIA: There’s more than a bit of Rhode Island at The New York Times. Publisher Arthur Gregg Sulzberger, of course, is a ProJo alum, as are reporter/columnist Dan Barry, Pentagon correspondent Helene Cooper, and reporters Michael Corkery and C.J. Chivers. Food critic Pete Wells hails from the Ocean State. A.O. Scott, who just signed off after a long run as film critic, to take a different role at the paper, graduated from Classical High. Brown alum and former Prov Phoenix contributor Jessica Grose is an opinion columnist and author. And congrats to Browns alum Kayla Guo and Gaya Gupta are signing on as fellows with the NYT, Guo in DC and Gupta in NYC. 

TO HELL WITH POVERTY: Sociologist Matthew Desmond is generating some buzz with his new book calling for the abolition of poverty. Here’s an excerpt from his interview with Fresh Air on NPR: “This one statistic that I calculated just blew me away. So a recent study was published and it showed that if the top 1% of Americans just paid the taxes they owed, not paid more taxes ... we as a nation could raise an additional $175 billion every year. That is just about enough to pull everyone out of poverty, every parent, every child, every grandparent. So we clearly have the resources to do this. It is not hard. This is a rough estimate. I arrive at this number by looking at everyone under the poverty line, calculating the average it would take to just bring them over the poverty line and adding that all up. It's pretty equivalent to what we could earn by just enforcing fair taxes at the very top of the market. What else could we do with $175 billion? We could more than double our investment in affordable housing. We could reestablish the extended child tax credit that we rolled out during COVID. ... [That]was basically a check for middle and low-income families with kids. That's all it was. And that simple intervention cut child poverty almost in half in six months. We could bring that back again with $175 billion and still have money left over.”

Ian Donnis can be reached at

2024 by East Bay Media Group

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.