APRA requests raise concerns about East Providence Flock program

Missing MOUs, a procurement problem, and lackluster data transparency

By Ethan Hartley
Posted 11/19/26

Riverside resident John Renquinha has had a busy month filing public records requests regarding the city's use of Flock cameras. Some of his findings warrant further discussion.

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Register to post events


If you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here.

Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content.

Day pass subscribers

Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.


APRA requests raise concerns about East Providence Flock program

Missing MOUs, a procurement problem, and lackluster data transparency

Posted

A series of Access to Public Records Act (APRA) requests filed by a local resident have raised fresh concerns and criticisms regarding the city’s Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) program with polarizing security camera company, Flock Safety.

John Renquinha, of Riverside, brought his findings to the East Providence City Council on Tuesday night after a busy couple of months filing multiple requests for what he believed should be public records regarding how the city entered into its contract with Flock, what data is captured, how the city shares the data captured (and with what other agencies it shares), and whether or not that data is as secure as the council was originally promised when they approved the five-year, $297,000 contract in May of 2023.

Renquinha’s original APRA, sent on Oct. 5, 2026, included a three-item wish list — audit logs of searches made within from the Flock database from Sept. 3, 2026 through Oct. 5, 2026; the police department’s written policies for training officers to use and access the Flock system; and the memorandum of understanding (MOU) with all other police departments, companies, and state/federal agencies who they were sharing the Flock data with.

He was unable to obtain two of those requests, but for very different reasons.

The department denied releasing the Flock audit logs, citing a subsection within the APRA law that states a public record may be denied if the information pertains to a criminal investigation or “could reasonably be expected to interfere with investigations of criminal activity or with enforcement proceedings.”

Flock audit logs, for context, include information such as the license plate captured, the reason a search for that plate was made, and by whom the request to run that plate was made. Whether or not they are deemed public documents is up to the discretion of local municipal bodies (such as police departments). Many police departments across the country release them as public documents, while others have been more hesitant. There is no overarching law deeming them public records in Rhode Island.

Renquinha protested the denial, but the department held firm.

Quentin McMullen, a Pawtucket resident who also came to the council meeting on Tuesday to talk about the Flock program in East Providence, summed up his concerns regarding this denial.

“The people deserve to know if there’s one police officer repeatedly searching for one person throughout the month, throughout the six months, throughout the year. That’s how the people can find out about Flock abuse,” he said, adding that Flock audit logs being made public were how New Bedford police officers were found to be track partners and ex-girlfriends just last month. “Without that, the police are saying ‘Give us a surveillance database, and you don’t get to know how we use it at all. Just trust us.’ And we see across the country that trust has been abused. Not making any accusations against our own police, but we know that trust can be abused.”

Missing MOU and procurement problem

The other request in Renquinha’s original APRA to be denied was not actually denied by a departmental decision to do so, but due to a much stranger reason.

The department apparently lost the original MOU outlining how data would be shared between agencies, and which agencies would have access. Both physical and digital copies were reportedly lost during their recent headquarters renovations.

“The MOUs were supposed to be a safeguard that we were supposed to know who access to our cameras, who has access to their cameras,” Renquinha said. “They were lost. All the MOUs and all that we’re sharing our data with. So the one safeguard we thought we had in place was lost.”

Renquinha made other records requests, too. Most pertinent to the purposes of this story is one he made asking the city for all documents regarding a bid specification for ALPRs, and any bid proposals that came in from vendors. He also specified that, if Flock was the sole bidder on a contract for the services requested, he could be provided with a sole source letter identifying them as the only company capable of delivering them.

City solicitor Michael Marcello responded on Oct. 29, 2026 that the city had no documents to provide for any of those requests.

Renquinha, who is no stranger to the state laws governing bid procurement (he is the DPW director for the Town of Barrington), said this was a clear violation of state law.

“You’re supposed to file a declaration letter when you have a bid on a contract like that. I looked up other cities and towns. Warwick did. East Greenwich, Providence, Pawtucket, they all have their declaration letters in place,” he said. “When you do that, it’s basically that you want to be a part of the club. You want to get into their little cameras and they want to get into your little cameras…All being part of the club, but you’re supposed to still follow state law, and state law is a declaration letter needs to be filed, or you put it out for bid.”

Mayor responds

In an interview Tuesday, Mayor Bob DaSilva said that the former police chief, Christopher Francesconi, approached him in 2023 with the idea to contract with Flock as it would link the city up with surrounding communities that had already done so, including Pawtucket, Providence, Seekonk, Woonsocket, and Cranston.

“We were the only city surrounded by a bunch of other municipalities that were utilizing it,” DaSilva said. “And my concern was, as criminals become wise as to where to avoid, I didn’t want to be an outlier surrounded by communities that were utilizing Flock, and now they’re going to look at East Providence as an easy target because they’re not going to get caught.”

DaSilva said that not producing a sole source letter was potentially a “step that we missed”.

“Could we have had our procurement department generate a letter saying it was a sole source? I’m sure they did. If they didn’t, it’s a step that we missed,” he said. “But this was a contract that was brought before the city council, it was voted on by the council, approved by the council. It doesn’t negate the fact that this was the sole provider in the region and the whole purpose of getting with Flock was so that we could help solve crimes locally by cooperating with our local law enforcement agencies.”

Police perspective

In an interview on Tuesday, Police Chief Michael Rapoza confirmed that the original MOU between the city and the agencies who they had agreed to share Flock access with were lost in the midst of upgrades occurring at the city’s police headquarters.

“During that process it appears either the physical or digital copies were stored away or misplaced,” he said. “We’ve made a concerted effort to try and locate those originals but unfortunately we were not successful.”

However, Rapoza said that this original MOU was no longer of consequence anyways, because the city has since adopted new policies and MOU language developed by the Rhode Island Police Chiefs Association to guide cities and towns on sharing ALPR data with one another.

“We have since fully complied with that and we’ve got all updated digital and physical copies of those MOUs for all the agencies we’re sharing with,” he said. “And obviously we’ll be keeping better track of those moving forward.”

Asked to provide a list of agencies the City of East Providence shares its data with, The Post was given a list that included the following: Central Falls PD; Cranston PD, Cumberland PD; Fall River PD; The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children; Newport PD; North Providence PD; Pawtucket PD; Providence PD, Rhode Island State Police; Seekonk PD; Smithfield PD; Somerset PD; Tiverton PD; Warwick PD; West Greenwich PD; and Woonsocket PD.

Rapoza said that the new statewide MOU ensured everyone was on the “same playing field” in regards to how they share data with one another, and that includes a strict policy not to share data that originated with another agency.

“In the MOU, the information is for that specific agency, for their specific investigation,” he said. “For instance, Barrington can’t call East Providence to get information from Cranston’s Flock data. We’d be in violation of the MOU.”

Asked specifically if the department was sharing its Flock data with federal agencies like ICE or Border Patrol, Rapoza said they were not. He also added that there had been no known incidents of unauthorized access of the city’s Flock data by either of those agencies.

“It’s [the data sharing policy] very explicit,” he said. “Specifically with Border Patrol or ICE in particular, that we as an agency, and Flock as a whole, does not share that information.”

As to how the sharing actually works, Rapoza said that it is managed within the Flock system to add agencies and permit or restrict what they can access.

“We will not share with another agency until we have a signed MOU in place,” Rapoza said. “Once that MOU is in place…we allow them access. We can limit or allow certain parameters on what they can search within our database. Basically, it’s license plates that we have captured within our city.”

Legislative changes coming soon?

Rapoza, who took the interview via phone while in the midst of a break while attending a New England Association of Chiefs of Police conference, said that the issue has become the dominant issue in modern policing throughout the country. He said that level of interest will ensure that well-rounded policy will follow when the legislature comes back into session.

“I just got out of a meeting…it was a roundtable, and I would say about 70% of the conversation was on ALPRs, ALPR technology, legislation, MOUs, policy, and it’s not just Rhode Island that is dealing with this. It’s New England and the country as a whole,” he said. “I think especially after these mid-terms, once everything starts coming into effect in January, I think you’ll start seeing a lot more legislative action and more control.”

For the time being, DaSilva once more doubled down on not being interested in canceling the Flock program in the city. He mentioned Providence inching closer to canceling their own ALPR program with skepticism.

“That’s going to be interesting to see what happens with the crime rate,” he said. “We’re not interested in getting rid of it here in East Providence.”

NOTE: Since our interview with Chief Rapoza and Mayor DaSilva, the city has updated their Flock transparency portal to include the list of agencies the city shares data with. 

2026 by East Bay Media Group

Barrington · Bristol · East Providence · Little Compton · Portsmouth · Tiverton · Warren · Westport
Meet our staff
Jim McGaw

A lifelong Portsmouth resident, Jim graduated from Portsmouth High School in 1982 and earned a journalism degree from the University of Rhode Island in 1986. He's worked two different stints at East Bay Newspapers, for a total of 18 years with the company so far. When not running all over town bringing you the news from Portsmouth, Jim listens to lots and lots and lots of music, watches obscure silent films from the '20s and usually has three books going at once. He also loves to cook crazy New Orleans dishes for his wife of 25 years, Michelle, and their two sons, Jake and Max.