PORTSMOUTH — Could covering large portions of two local reservoirs with floating solar panels improve drinking water quality? And what would it mean for nearby homeowners, farmers and other …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
Register to post eventsIf you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here. Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content. |
Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.
PORTSMOUTH — Could covering large portions of two local reservoirs with floating solar panels improve drinking water quality? And what would it mean for nearby homeowners, farmers and other residents?
Those questions — along with concerns about noise, property values and profits — surfaced Thursday, Nov. 12, as the Portsmouth Planning Board reviewed a proposal for St. Mary’s and Sisson ponds.
The City of Newport, which owns the reservoirs, is working with solar developers BlueWave and Laketricity to install floating solar arrays on both bodies of water, part of Newport’s public drinking water system.
Robert Schultz Jr., Newport’s utilities director, said the city initially brushed aside inquiries from floating solar companies. But as water quality deteriorated, officials reconsidered.
All five of Newport’s reservoirs are classified as impaired, he said, and shading the water could reduce algae growth, evaporation and rising temperatures. “The benefits were too much to ignore,” Schultz said.
The preliminary proposal calls for a combined installation of approximately 44 megawatts of peak generating capacity, with solar panels covering substantial portions of both ponds. The sites were selected partly because electrical transmission lines are nearby.
No vote was taken, and town officials haven’t determined what approvals would be required.
Who benefits?
While promoted primarily as a way to improve drinking water quality, the project would also be a commercial solar installation.
Planning board member Luke Harding questioned whether Portsmouth residents would benefit from the electricity generated.
Schultz confirmed that the company would sell power to the grid, although financial arrangements have not been finalized.
Harding expressed frustration with solar projects that benefit investors rather than local residents. “Again, it’s for profit for somebody else, for somebody off the island,” he said. “If that electricity stayed on the island there would be a lot more attraction.”
Schultz maintained that the benefits to Newport Water would flow back to customers. The proposed lease would run at least 20 years, with possible 10-year extensions.
The developers also cite potential savings in water treatment costs and revenue for the reservoir owner, although the financial benefits and projected water quality improvements remain uncertain.
Anticipated concerns from neighbors
Board members questioned how the installations would affect nearby properties, particularly those overlooking the reservoirs.
Harding cited complaints from residents near other solar developments who believe their property values have declined. He warned that homeowners might demand lower tax assessments if their views were affected.
Another member questioned whether damaged panels could contaminate the water, noting that livestock drink from Sisson Pond. Schultz said neighboring property owners have no legal rights to use the reservoirs, although Newport wants to maintain good relationships with them.
Questions also focused on ice, snow, fluctuating water levels and noise.
The developers said the floating arrays are designed to rise and fall with water levels and withstand winter conditions. The system would connect directly to the electrical grid, without battery storage.
Harding noted that transformers at other solar installations have produced audible humming despite assurances to neighbors. Schultz said noise could be addressed through sound barriers.
The developers said floating panels sit at a shallower angle than conventional ground-mounted panels, reducing glare.
Preliminary visual simulations show the installations largely screened from public roads by vegetation and topography, although portions could be visible from Jepson Lane, Sisson Pond Road and Union Street.
The panels would rise approximately 20 inches above the water and be set back from the shoreline.
What happens after 20 years?
Board members also questioned the equipment’s lifespan and eventual removal.
A company representative said panels typically need replacement after about 20 years, although some existing installations have operated for 13 years without problems.
The developers said the floating structures could be dismantled and removed. Their presentation outlines a process involving removal of panels, electrical equipment and other components, followed by site restoration.
Financial guarantees for eventual removal were also discussed.
Uncharted territory
Town Planner Lea Hitchen said Portsmouth’s zoning ordinance does not specifically address floating solar installations, leaving officials uncertain about the approval process.
“The planning department still has to figure out, with Newport, the process,” she said.
Options include special-use permits, planning board approval or another review procedure. Hitchen said town attorneys would help determine the appropriate path.
“We’re going to have to bring legal in to narrow down the process. This is not a land use identified in our zoning ordinance,” she said.
Hitchen encouraged anyone with questions to contact the Planning Department so their concerns could be forwarded to the appropriate officials.