To the editor:
I've been observing the ongoing debate in town regarding the planned changes to the ninth and tenth grade English classes and wanted to share a suggestion on how we might resolve …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
Register to post eventsIf you'd like to post an event to our calendar, you can create a free account by clicking here. Note that free accounts do not have access to our subscriber-only content. |
Are you a day pass subscriber who needs to log in? Click here to continue.
To the editor:
I've been observing the ongoing debate in town regarding the planned changes to the ninth and tenth grade English classes and wanted to share a suggestion on how we might resolve this contentious issue.
Having listened to the various perspectives, I think the best way forward would be to retain the existing ninth and tenth grade honors English classes while also offering the planned new ninth and tenth grade English classes with the optional honors projects. All entering ninth and tenth graders would be free to choose their preferred English course each year, and all students would have the opportunity to earn honors distinction, either by pursuing a voluntary honors project or by completing an open-enrollment honors course with more rigorous and intensive content on a daily basis.
As I understand it, the primary motivation for the planned changes to the ninth and tenth grade English classes is to offer access to the honors designation for all students, and I very much agree with this effort to promote inclusivity and equal opportunity for all. At the same time, as a parent of children at both the high school and the middle school, it's clear to me that students who have reached high school should be given the choice of taking more challenging courses on a daily basis, if they wish, rather than offering only one uniform English course per grade level and transferring the honors component to an optional project - with that optional project becoming the only route toward honors distinction in ninth and tenth grade English classes. There is also the likelihood that many highly capable students who are busy with extracurricular activities and athletics will end up not completing optional honors projects on grounds that their schedules are already jam-packed.
Given these factors as well as the very significant opposition in the school community to the planned elimination of the honors English courses, I hope the high school will instead offer its students and families the best of both worlds with two different pathways for all ninth and tenth graders to earn honors distinction in their English classes. This strategy would enrich the course offerings in English for all students at the high school and could also be applied to expand the pathways for honors distinction in other departments, as well.
Sincerely,
Hans Schattle
Barrington